Stay Sharp in Every Splash: 2023’s Top Eyeliner Picks

By Fani

Waterproof eyeliner is a must-have in every makeup arsenal, providing long-lasting, smudge-free results for those special occasions or everyday wear. Whether you’re attending a wedding, hitting the gym, or just battling the heat and humidity, waterproof eyeliner ensures that your eyes remain beautifully framed and defined no matter what the day brings.

When it comes to finding the perfect waterproof eyeliner, the options seem endless. From pencils and gel liners to liquid and marker-style eyeliners, there’s something for everyone. However, what makes a waterproof eyeliner truly exceptional is its ability to stay put through tears, sweat, and even a dip in the pool, all while maintaining its rich color and smooth application.

Navigating the world of waterproof eyeliners can be overwhelming, which is why it’s crucial to consider aspects like the type of applicator, formulation, staying power, and ease of removal. Some people may prefer a fine-tipped pen for precise lines, while others might opt for the versatility of a smudge-proof gel liner. No matter your preference, finding the perfect match is essential for achieving that coveted, long-lasting eyeliner look.

We couldn’t be more excited to share our findings with you after hours of testing and researching numerous waterproof eyeliners. Get ready to discover the top performers that made the cut, ensuring your eyes stay stunningly lined and smudge-free throughout the day.

Best Waterproof Eyeliners

We have curated a fantastic list of the best waterproof eyeliners for you below. Dive into our collection and find the perfect eyeliner to make your eyes pop while staying smudge-free all day long!

Maybelline New York Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Black Eyeliner, Onyx

We think you should consider this eyeliner for its impressive smudge-resistance, waterproof quality, and self-sharpening tip.

Pros

  • Smudge-resistant and waterproof
  • Self-sharpening tip for convenience
  • Easy to create different looks

Cons

  • Limited to one color (black)
  • Might smudge with excessive sweat
  • Can be harder to remove

When we first tried the Maybelline New York Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Eyeliner, we were impressed by its smooth application. With its self-sharpening tip, creating precise lines or bold looks was a breeze. The waterproof formula truly lived up to its name, resisting smudges and looking fresh throughout the day.

However, if you’re someone who prefers a variety of colors, this eyeliner may feel limiting as it currently only comes in black. While it’s excellent for most situations, keep in mind that it can smudge under extreme heat or sweat, so be cautious if you’ll be wearing it for intense activities.

Another factor to consider is that the long-lasting, waterproof nature of this eyeliner can make it trickier to remove. We recommend using a reliable makeup remover to ensure it comes off easily at the end of the day.

Overall, if you’re looking for a waterproof and smudge-resistant eyeliner with a convenient self-sharpening tip, the Maybelline Unstoppable Eyeliner could be a great choice for you. It allows for versatility in your eye looks and can stay put even during your busy days. Just make sure to have a good makeup remover on hand when it’s time to take it off.

Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner

This waterproof eyeliner should be your go-to choice for a long-lasting, smudge-proof, and versatile eye makeup experience.

Pros

  • Long-wearing, waterproof formula
  • Built-in sharpener and smudger
  • Variety of styles and looks achievable

Cons

  • May not last the full 24 hours for some users
  • Sharpener may cause breakage
  • Can be tricky to remove without proper makeup remover

From our firsthand experience, the Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner is a game-changer in the world of eye makeup. The new, improved formula easily glides on and stays put where it should be for up to 24 hours. We love how its creamy consistency allows for precise lines and smooth application.

Moreover, this versatile pencil eyeliner comes with a built-in sharpener and smudger, making it even more practical. Whether we’re going for a classic cat-eye or a high-drama smoky look, this eyeliner helps us achieve our desired results with ease. Plus, it’s available in 8 ophthalmologist-tested shades to suit different preferences.

However, even though it is advertised to last up to 24 hours, we noticed that the staying power might vary for some users. Furthermore, the built-in sharpener has caused some breakage issues in a few cases. It’s essential to remove the eyeliner properly using a waterproof makeup remover, as it can be challenging to take off otherwise.

In conclusion, the Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner is an excellent choice for those who want a long-lasting, waterproof eyeliner that offers versatility and practicality. Although some minor drawbacks may arise, the pros outweigh the cons, making this product a must-try for eyeliner enthusiasts.

NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner

We believe this impressive waterproof eyeliner is a must-have for anyone looking to create the perfect cat-eye look.

Pros

  • Long-lasting and waterproof
  • Ultra precise and flexible tip
  • Cruelty-free and vegan formula

Cons

  • May smudge on oily eyelids
  • Occasional tip-fraying
  • Requires practice for precise application

We recently tried the NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner, and we’re thrilled with the results! This waterproof eyeliner delivers an intense matte black finish, making the perfect cat-eye look achievable with ease and precision. The highly pigmented formula lasts all day without fading or smudging.

The ultra-precise and flexible brush tip is one of our favorite features. The easy-to-use design allows us to control the thickness of the lines, whether we want to create fine, natural strokes or go for a bold, dramatic look. The brush glides smoothly across the eyelid for seamless, defined lines.

We appreciate that NYX Professional Makeup is a cruelty-free and vegan brand. It’s essential for us to know that no animals were harmed in the making of this fantastic product. Overall, we highly recommend the NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner for those seeking a waterproof, long-lasting, and precise eyeliner to enhance their makeup game.

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil

No products found.

We think you’ll love this mechanical eyeliner pencil for its intense pigmentation, lasting power, and affordable price.

Pros

  • Creamy formula glides effortlessly
  • Smudge-proof and long-lasting
  • Cruelty-free brand

Cons

  • May break off easily
  • Limited color options
  • Possible issues with longevity

We recently tried the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil and we must say, it made our eyes pop! The creamy formula allows for easy application, and the intense pigmentation covers like a liquid liner. We really appreciate how smoothly it glides on, making it easy for us to create the perfect winged look.

One thing we love about this eyeliner is that it’s smudge-proof and lasts all day, even in heat and humidity. No more worrying about eyeliner bleeding or transferring throughout the day! And since NYX is a cruelty-free brand, we can feel good about supporting a company that doesn’t test on animals.

However, there are a few drawbacks we feel are worth noting. The pencil has a tendency to break off easily, so application can be tricky at times. Additionally, there are limited color options, which may be a downside for those wanting to experiment with different shades. Lastly, some users report issues with the longevity of the product, which may not last as long as other high-end alternatives.

Overall, we believe the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil is a fantastic, affordable choice for those seeking a smudge-proof and smooth-gliding eyeliner. With a cruelty-free brand and easy application, it’s definitely worth a try!

stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

No products found.

We highly recommend this eyeliner for all-day wear, thanks to its incredible staying power and precision.

Pros

  • Long-lasting formula
  • Precise application with fine marker-like tip
  • Intense, smooth black finish

Cons

  • Not entirely sweat-proof
  • May smudge slightly on greasy eyelids
  • Requires drying time before blinking

We recently discovered the stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, and it has quickly become our go-to eyeliner. The fine marker-like tip offers incredible precision, whether you’re a makeup novice or a pro. This liquid liner glides on smoothly and dries quickly to reveal an intense black finish that lasts all day. With its waterproof formula, it’s perfect for those hot or rainy days when you need your makeup to stay put.

However, no product is without its drawbacks. While the stila liner is water-resistant, it is not entirely sweat-proof. So, if you’re participating in any water sports or intense physical activities, you may want to look for something a little more resilient. Additionally, this liner may smudge slightly if you have particularly greasy eyelids. To avoid this, we recommend using a good eye primer before application to help keep it in place.

That said, once the stila eyeliner dries down, it has fantastic staying power and minimal transfer. As long as you give it a moment to dry fully before opening your eyes, you should have minimal issues with smudging. Overall, the stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner is an excellent addition to anyone’s makeup routine. And with its impressive staying power, precision, and intense black finish, you’ll look stunning from day to night.

Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner

We highly recommend this eyeliner for its ultra-smooth application and long-lasting, smudge-proof formula.

Pros

  • High intensity color for a bold look
  • Creamy, smooth texture that glides on effortlessly
  • Waterproof and sweat-proof for all-day wear

Cons

  • May be challenging to find a suitable sharpener
  • Requires makeup remover for thorough cleaning
  • Needs frequent sharpening to maintain precision

When we tried the Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner, we couldn’t help but be impressed by the high-intensity color it provided. The ultra-smooth formula made it a breeze to apply along our lash lines without any tugging or skipping.

We put this eyeliner’s waterproof claims to the test and found that it didn’t disappoint. Even during hot weather, it managed to stay put and resist smudging from sweat. We were delighted with the long-lasting, smudge-proof results.

There’s no doubt that we love this eyeliner, but there are a few cons to be aware of. Finding the right sharpener can be a bit challenging due to the pencil’s thick plastic casing. Additionally, removing this waterproof formula at the end of the day may require a dedicated makeup remover rather than your usual cleanser. Lastly, to maintain its precision, this eyeliner needs to be sharpened frequently.

In conclusion, the Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner offers an incredible color payoff, smooth application, and long-lasting, smudge-proof wear. The few cons can be easily managed and do not outweigh the benefits of this fantastic product.

e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner

We highly recommend this eyeliner for its waterproof, long-lasting wear, and creamy formula.

Pros

  • Waterproof and long-lasting
  • Ultra-pigmented and creamy
  • Vegan and cruelty-free

Cons

  • Might smudge a bit
  • Not suitable for sensitive eyes
  • Multiple layers needed for intense color

After trying out the e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, we adore its waterproof and ultra-pigmented formula that creates bold and defined lines. The creamy consistency glides on smoothly, making it easy for us to apply on our lash line, waterline, or even all over the eyelid.

One drawback we noticed is that it might smudge slightly, but this is a minor issue. The fact that it’s both vegan and cruelty-free makes us feel good about using this product, knowing it aligns with our ethical values. However, for those with sensitive eyes, take note that it might cause some irritation.

The e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner provides all-day wear, ensuring our eyes look fabulous without the need for frequent touch-ups. Although it may require a few layers to achieve a dark and intense look, it’s worth it for the end results. Overall, if you’re on the lookout for a reliable and waterproof eyeliner, give this a try!

Buying Guide

We are so excited to help you find the perfect waterproof eyeliner! Choosing the right one can be a bit overwhelming, but don’t worry, we’ve got you covered. Let’s dive into some key features to consider when shopping for the best waterproof eyeliner.

First and foremost, long-lasting formula is essential. We want our eyeliner to stay put all day long without smudging or fading. Look for a product that promises long wear time, and remember that sometimes it’s worth the extra investment for a truly durable formula.

Now, let’s talk about the tip of the eyeliner. There are a few different options to choose from:

  • Pencil: This is the classic choice, great for those who like more control during application. Just make sure the pencil is waterproof!
  • Liquid: If you’re a fan of sleek, dramatic lines, liquid eyeliner is your friend. A waterproof liquid liner should be quick drying and smudge-proof.
  • Gel: Gel eyeliners are similar to liquid ones, but they’re often more comfortable on the eyes and don’t crack as easily over time.

Application and Precision

No matter which type of eyeliner you choose, the ease of application and precision are essential for achieving that flawless look. Look for a product with a comfortable and easy-to-hold applicator, whether it’s a brush or a pen. A fine and precise tip is key to achieving those sharp wings and intricate designs we all love.

Color and Pigmentation

The color and pigmentation of your waterproof eyeliner should be taken into consideration as well. We recommend choosing a highly pigmented liner for bold and vibrant lines that won’t disappear during the day. While classic black is always a popular choice, don’t be afraid to explore other colors like brown, blue, or even metallic shades!

Remember, the best waterproof eyeliner for you will ultimately depend on your preferences and needs. Keep these important features in mind when shopping, and you’ll be on your way to finding the perfect product for all those poolside parties and rainy days! Happy hunting!

Avatar for Fani
Author

Fani

Leave a Comment